W612 Characterization

I tested W612 for air permeability and burst pressure, shown below.

It should be noted that the air permeability and burst pressure values are comparable to W504; looks like a good reproduction! I also tested a sample with the hexane residue and debris, no difference in permeability or burst pressure was seen.

Background pores included (0,0)

Background pores removed (0,0)

Background pores included (0,4)

Background pores removed (0,4)

Similar Posts

9 Comments

  1. Was there anything different about the membranes you burst tested that failed ~2-3 PSI? Debris on the edges, perhaps? I also think you meant to say that w504 had a cutoff of ~29 nm.

  2. There was no debris on the membranes with lower burst pressures, one of them did have the pentane spots however. I also tested another “spotted membrane” and this had a BP of 7. I did mean 29nm, sorry.

  3. I think we should produce histograms w and w/o the background ‘pores’ and show size-by-side images of the original TEM and the one with pores outlined. This will allow folks to make their own judgement and use the numbers they trust for their purposes.

  4. I added histograms with and without background pores, along with the images used to create them.

  5. The image for “(0,0) background pores removed” is the same as “(0,4) background pores removed”.

  6. What do you do to remove the “background pores”? I see changes at many pore sizes in the histograms, so you are not just using a size cutoff…

    Also, if the flow rates are correct, many of the small pores must be open, since there are large differences in the density of the biggest pores… How do these measurements compare to Maryna’s theory – Maryna?

  7. All I did to remove the smaller pores is change the threshold, though I realize now that I should assign a cutoff, as changing the threshold changes all the sizes.

  8. Yeah, I’m not sure how to best make this adjustment, there are arguments for both thresholding and applying a size cutoff.  Obviously, the objective to to most accurately reflect reality…

Comments are closed.